Do you think that the 'I hate Brenda' book ...

[Ashley]

Now those of you that remember 'Beverly Hills 90210' Shannens other major hit show prior to Charmed that Shannen back then had the 'Bad Girl' image and the book 'I hate Brenda/Shannen Doherty Exposed' did;nt help matters, for me I think people confused the chracter of brenda, and people assumed that was Shannen as well - even though shannen defended herself at various different times pointing out that she was not brenda.

Hench why she left the show and did'nt want to return

I vote yes

[Laura]

i havent voted yet but i do agree also i found this quote she once said...

"I wish I had conducted myself better on occasion and been more private, but I would rather live my life to the fullest than constantly conduct myself in a certain way to gain approval from others, I’ve always been outspoken about my opinions, and there’s something to be said for having the courage to just live your life. I have regrets but no apologies."

I think thats a very positive attitude and ok mayeb there were things she cudda done differently but she has been herself as opposed to the celebrities that put on a fake persona to be accepted and i just hate that be yourself and why not stand up for yourself that doesnt make you a bitch!

Love you Shay xx

[piperphoebeprue]

Yeah, I think it did, yeah, I agree with what you said Ashley.